Readify

Dog

The Man Who Laughs

Dog is the domesticated animal against which the novel measures the outlawed Wolf. In Ursus’s comic address to the audience, its supposed virtues—service, humility, and sociability—become a pointed contrast with the wildness that authorities use to condemn the Green Box’s animal companion.

The Dog in Ursus’s Address

Ursus introduces Homo as a Wolf, then provocatively calls him a perfected Dog. The shift is rhetorical rather than zoological: Homo is praised for adapting himself to human company, barking as a concession to civilization while still howling in sympathy with people. Dog thus represents a model of animal usefulness and accommodation, even as Ursus’s joke unsettles the boundary between domestic animal and wild creature.

Ursus extends the praise into an ethical portrait. Dog is described as humble, helpful, and charitable, giving without drawing attention to its good deeds. Its bodily gestures are part of the joke as well: it sweats through its tongue and seems to smile with its tail. By assigning generosity and cordiality to an animal, Ursus turns the comparison into a teasing rebuke to human pretensions.

Dog and Wolf in English Law

The distinction becomes consequential when the Green Box is attacked. The opponents’ stated pretext is that Dog is allowable but Wolf is forbidden: England accepts the animal that barks, not the one that howls. The contrast makes domestication a legal category as well as a behavioral one, with the yard standing on the protected side of the boundary and the woods on the outlawed side.

Petitions from the rectors and vicars of five Southwark parishes invoke statutes placing Wolf beyond the law’s protection. They seek the imprisonment of Gwynplaine and the execution of Wolf, or at least their banishment. To present the animal as a public danger, the petitioners also appeal to London physicians, who claim that a person who sees a Wolf first will be hoarse for life and may be bitten. Dog’s permitted status is therefore sharpened by the contrast with the dangers attributed to Wolf.

Narrative Significance

Dog’s brief appearances expose how easily a distinction between tame and wild becomes a distinction between lawful and outlawed. Ursus’s speech treats animal conduct with comic sympathy, while the authorities’ petitions turn Wolf into a threat to public order. The same comparison that celebrates Dog’s companionship also reveals the power of official language to classify a creature—and to use that classification against the people associated with it.

Related StoryFlow